The Hypocrisy of Dutch Actions in Indonesia
Asian Research Journal of Arts & Social Sciences,
At the end of World War 2 the Netherlands, through its own military tribunals, tried and convicted several members of the Japanese and German militaries for their participation in the war crime of extra judicial executions in Indonesia and the Netherlands. Several of the convicted men were executed by the Netherlands while others sentenced to lengthy prison terms. From 1946-1949 the Netherlands, primarily through commando Raymond Westerling, engaged in the same actions they accused the Japanese of having committed. While no specific order was ever revealed showing that Westerling’s actions were ordered by the military, the Netherlands tacitly approved his actions by failing to control him and his men and by their unwillingness to take responsibility for his actions before or after the Netherlands withdrew its forces from Indonesia in 1949. This research paper explores the extrajudicial executions conducted by Westerling, his men, other Dutch military and the Dutch government in order to provide a better and more thorough understanding of these events and the lack of national or international action against war crimes committed after World War 2. It concludes that the Netherlands has failed to try or even accuse Westerling and others of war crimes or take actions to discipline them, and in fact has covered up his actions and failed to make public those war crimes. Further that the reason for this continued hypocritical refusal is a concern for the reputation of the Netherlands in the world and a belief that high levels of government would be found complicit.
- War crimes
- summary execution
- mass murder
How to Cite
Swirc M. The Snowball then rolls on”, De Groene Amsterdammer;2019. The National Archives, “Singapore: extradition of Captain RPP Westerling.
FCO 141/15495, retrieved from Singapore: extradition of Captain RPP Westerling the National Archives on May 21, 2021.cc
Green, Penny, Tony Ward. State Crime: Governments, Violence and Corruption. Pluto Press, London and Virginia; 2004.
Paulose, Regina Menachery, Ronald Gordon Rogo. Addressing Colonial Crimes Through Reparations: The Mau Mau, Herero and Nama. State Crime Journal. 2018;7(2):369-388.
Laurinaviciute L, Paulose R, Rogo R. The Forgotten: The Armenian Genocide 100 Years Later”, in M. Bergsmo and W.L. Cheah, eds, Historical Origins of International Criminal Law. Brussels: Torkel Opsahl Academic. 2014;1.
Law Reports of Trial of War Criminals, Vol. XIII, Susuki Motosuke-Execution of Dutch and Indonesian Civilians, English Edition (loc.gov). Retrieved on May 1, 2021.
Piccigallo P. The Japanese on Trial: Alleged War Crimes Operations in the East 1945-1951. University of Texas Press;1979.
Borch, Fred. Military trials of war criminals in the Netherlands East Indies 1946-1949, New York, NY: Oxford University Press;2017.
Westerling R. Challenge to Terror. Pub. Read Books, Ltd;2008.
Van den Herik, Larissa. Addressing 'Colonial Crimes' through Reparations? Adjudicating Dutch Atrocities Committed in Indonesia. Journal of International Criminal Justice. 2012;10(3):693–705
Oostindie, Gert & Hoogenboom, Ireen & Verwey, Jonathan. “The decolonization war in Indonesia, 1945–1949: War crimes in Dutch veterans’ egodocuments”. War in History. 2018;25;254-276. DOI:10.1177/0968344517696525.
Vickers, Adrian. A History Modern of Indonesia (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press;2013.
Ashton HS. The Netherlands at War. London, 1941;24-5. Retrieved on July 11, 2021, from Hyper War: The Netherlands at War (Chapter 2) (ibiblio.org)
Gordon, Alec. How Big was Indonesia’s ‘‘Real’’ Colonial Surplus in 1878–1941? Center for Southeast Asian Studies, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok 10330, Thailand Journal of Contemporary Asia. 2012;42(4):560–580.
Netherlands Law Concerning Trials of War Criminals. Accessed on July 28, 2021. https://www.legal-tools.org/doc/8a2831/pdf/
Ricklefs MC. A History of Modern Indonesia Since c.1300. San Francisco: Stanford University Press;1991.
Limpach R. Business As Usual: Dutch Mass Violence in the Indonesian War of Independence. Colonial Counterinsurgency and Mass Violence: The Dutch Empire in Indonesia. Ed. Luttikhuis and Moses. Taylor and Francis, pub;2014.
VP 29 Rapport Commissie Goede Diensten 1948 (figshare.com). Retrieved on May 1, 2021.
Scagliola S. “Cleo’s ‘Unfinished Business’: Coming to Terms with Dutch War Crimes in Indonesia’s War of Independence. Colonial Counterinsurgency and Mass Violence: The Dutch Empire in Indonesia. Luttikhuis and Moses, ed., Taylor and Francis, pub;2014.
Bosma U. “Why is there no post-colonial debate in the Netherlands?”, Post-Colonial Immigrants and Identity Formations in the Netherlands. Amsterdam University Press;2012.
Statement by King Willem-Alexander at the beginning of the state visit to Indonesia, October 3, 2020. Statement by King Willem-Alexander at the beginning of the state visit to Indonesia | Speech | Royal House of the Netherlands (royal-house.nl), retrieved on July 18, 2021.
Luttikhuis B, Moses A. Colonial Counterinsurgency and Mass Violence: The Dutch Empire in Indonesia. Taylor and Francis, pub;2011.
Abstract View: 101 times
PDF Download: 37 times